Have you taken the Etsy Taste Test ? It did come up with a few things that I really liked, and is fun!
Here are a few things mine came up with (click on photo for link):
Earrings by Jewelryvixen
Bunting by Twostringjane
Notecards by thewheatfield
Perfume oils by ForStrangeWomen
Suede necklace by HaKNiK